Share/Save/Bookmark

Manchin, Raese clash at U.S. Senate debate

U S Senate seal

By Ben Adducchio

This audio player requires Adobe Flash
October 19, 2010 · It was a mostly civil discussion between the two front-runners for the Senate seat formerly held by the late Senator Robert C Byrd during a debate in Morgantown Monday.

But the candidates clashed on how to reform health care and how to improve the country’s economy.

 

Democratic Gov. Joe Manchin and Republican businessman John Raese sat at opposite ends of a long table during the debate.

 

They rarely exchanged looks, but they did exchange criticisms.

 

At the debate, Raese attacked Manchin as being too supportive of President Obama’s administration’s policies. He’s claimed Manchin would be a rubber stamp for Obama, and Manchin reiterated a phrase of his that’s become more common as this election has progressed.

 

“I’m not a rubber stamp for anybody, and never have been in my life. In the spirit of Sen. Byrd, he didn’t care who the President was,” Manchin said.

 

“If they were wrong, they were wrong, no matter what political party. And I will operate in the same vein.”

 

Raese says Manchin is a career politician, and accused Manchin of priding himself on special interests.

 

Raese says President Obama and Manchin would work together to keep America on what he says is the wrong track.  

 

“We have a country right now that I think is going in the wrong direction,” Raese said.

 

“I’d like an opportunity to go to the United States Senate and put the country in the right direction,” he said, “a country based on free-enterprise, capitalism. I want to see the United States rise again.”

 

Raese and Manchin disagreed on how to reform health care.

 

Raese wants to repeal the legislation Congress passed earlier this year, which he calls Obamacare. Manchin disagrees.

 

“I’m not prepared to scrap the entire bill, there are parts that need changed,” he said, “but let me tell you, I’m not prepared to tell your child who had a pre-existing condition, that he or she can’t be covered. There’s a lot of good in the bill that basically Democrats and Republicans agree with.”

 

But not Raese. And he pulled no punches when discussing his issues with the legislation.

 

“It is pure, unadulterated Socialism, it is the worst bill that has ever come out of the United States Senate and House,” he said.

 

“I think right now, when you look at the gross domestic product in this country, with Obamacare, you’re looking at the fact that we’re over almost 51 percent of the GDP in this country will be controlled by the federal government, unacceptable.”

 

There are four candidates running for the seat.

 

The other two are Mountain Party Candidate Jesse Johnson, and Jeff Becker of the Constitution Party.

 

Becker says he’s an avid supporter of a smaller federal government, and that Democrats and Republicans alike haven’t worked to achieve that.

 

“Most of these federal departments really aren’t authorized by the Constitution,” he said.

 

“We need to look at these and phase them out, we need to phase out as many of these federal programs as we can.”

 

Jesse Johnson spoke adamantly about a key issue he says is important to West Virginia and the nation - diversifying our energy economy.

 

“More energy shines on the surface of this planet in one day, than all of mankind consumes in a year,” Johnson said.

 

“We have tremendous options, and no political will in Washington or the state of West Virginia to explore them, and to incentivize them.”

 

Outside the studios, a few dozen activists held signs, representing both Manchin and Raese supporters.

 

Many were West Virginia University students.

 

Colin Shock is a political science major. He supports Manchin.

 

“I don’t think West Virginia is going to vote out someone who’s been serving this state for years and years,” he said.

 

“I really believe Manchin is going to win.”

 

Daniel Brummage is another student at WVU.

 

He held a sign saying “Can’t Spell Obama without MBA, Neither Can Heather Bresch.”

 

This refers to a degree scandal at the university, involving Manchin’s daughter. 

 

An investigation concluded Bresch was awarded an MBA degree she didn’t earn, which was rescinded.

 

Brummage says he wants Raese to win.

 

“He’s less known than Manchin is, with Manchin being governor,” Brummage said.

 

“Just the exposure that comes from a debate like this, he can set the record straight on a few of the things Manchin has been slandering him about. It’s a great opportunity for him.”

 

The election is scheduled for November 2.

Loading
Latest News :

By Ashton Marra

Legislative interims in Wheeling this week have lawmakers considering a variety of issues that will develop over the next year. One of the biggest of those, the state’s Medicaid expansion.

By Beth Vorhees and Cecelia Mason

One of the main issues that had to be settled when western Virginia broke away from Virginia to form a new state- was slavery.

By Dave Mistich

Imagine this: each of the 86-ton columns of the capitol building transformed into 3-D scenes representing the history and culture of West Virginia. That's what's in store for anyone in Charleston who wonders down to the capitol building beginning Thursday night to celebrate a century and a half of statehood. With a dozen specialized projectors and a crew that’s been working since Monday to build the scene, this event promises to be the most extravagant and high-tech display during the state’s 150th birthday celebration.

By Roxy Todd, Allegheny Mountain Radio

And here's an unusual way to celebrate West Virginia's 150 years. In memory of the Battle of Droop Mountain, park superintendent Mike Smith is planning to invite hikers to walk in the footsteps of the soldiers who fought it. He’s leading a memorial march into battle, along steep mountain trails and a federal highway.

By Ashton Marra

The state House of Delegates has officially elected a new leader to take former Speaker Rick Thompson’s position. Delegate Tim Miley of Harrison County was elected by members of the House during a special session yesterday, but it still remains to be seen if some committee chairs will hold their positions under the new leadership.
[First] [Previous] [Next] [Last]
West Virginia Public Broadcasting is a member station of: