Loading
Join Us. 170 Million Americans for Public Broadcasting

Our Blog Usage Policy


Want to comment on a blog?

Login and post your comment


Log In
 
 

Register for a free account

Forgot your Password?

SPONSOR
Goodwill Indistries of Kanwha Valley Inc.

Classically Speaking

Classical music in West Virginia and Beyond

Dark days, light music?

(Commentary) Permanent link   All Posts

By Mona Seghatoleslami

It’s a cold, rainy afternoon.  As I organize the library here, I’ve been idly pondering what music I should play tomorrow on the radio. Not sure if it’s all the rain, but I’ll admit I’m not in the sunniest of moods.  I found myself lining up in my head an afternoon of late-romantic symphonies, desperately melancholy string quartets, and perhaps a requiem or two. 

And then I caught myself…what am I doing?  Is this really what I want to hear? Is this what everyone else wants to hear?  So I've abandoned the library for a bit to write down my thoughts and see what other people think.

Do you generally want music that fits your mood or counters it? 

Are dark days (emotionally or weather-wise) well-suited to some darker Elgar, Prokofiev, or Sibelius?  Or are they exactly the time to brighten things up with Haydn’s “Sunrise” Quartet, early Mozart piano concertos, or some Leroy Anderson miniatures?

 (And what are your exceptions?  And are there some pieces fit many of your moods?  Or is this all a pretty silly line of inquiry?)

Talk to me…meanwhile, I’m keeping it bleak with Nielsen’s String Quartet in F Minor, Op. 5


I’m going to tell a story instead of answering your question.

I chose music for someone else to hear two times last weekend. Both times I was limited to what was already on my mp3 player. Both times were at my church, though neither was during a worship service (so I didn’t feel limited to so-called religious music). My choice was influenced by two very different listening situations.

Saturday afternoon I was going to do some maintenance work and wanted music playing while I worked in what I expected to be an empty building. It seemed like a good time to play a recently received John Coltrane album or maybe some Brian Setzer. I discovered upon my arrival someone was already there taking down Christmas decorations. They accepted my offer of a few minutes of help removing some decorations we could reach only from a ladder. I had only a moment to think about my audience before selecting “The Essential Electric Light Orchestra”. I interpreted the other person’s comment of “Oh, ELO. I have their albums.” as meaning I made a good choice. After we finished, my colleague left and I went on to my project. Unfortunately, I found I had to shut off the electricity to the system amplifying my mp3 player. No music for me.

Sunday morning I wasn’t quite satisfied with the performance of the sound system during the first of two worship services. After the service I wanted to use my mp3 player as an input while I started fixing the problem. A few people were lingering to talk with friends. Hmmm, it probably wasn’t the right time to reprise “Sweet Talkin’ Woman”. The mental image of a Sunday morning jazz club stopped me from playing the Coltrane I didn’t play on Saturday. Then I thought of Weber’s first clarinet concerto. The content should be unobjectionable. It isn’t heard too often. It wouldn’t call attention to what I was doing if I needed it to play for awhile, unlike the day I unsuccessfully tried to get a reaction from a music student by doing a sound check using an album of music of the Renaissance performed on period instruments. A few minutes into the Weber I noticed a woman with a serious expression waiting alone for someone attending a meeting in another room. Realizing some people intensely dislike orchestral music, I asked if she had any objections to my choice of music. She said she was enjoying it! The sound system problem was quickly solved, but I played the entire album. Perhaps I was fantasizing about performing what I was hearing. Some other people arriving for the second service commented they liked hearing music as they entered the church and wondered if I planned to play something every week.

I hope your selections were received even better.

Jim K.
Posted by: Radio at 1/12/2009 2:36 PM


Symphony No. 3 - Poco Allegretto by Brahms always evokes a wintery scene to me
Posted by: aorr at 1/28/2009 11:13 PM


Leave a comment
Name *
Email *
Homepage
Comment

West Virginia Public Broadcasting is a member station of: