Loading
Join Us. 170 Million Americans for Public Broadcasting

Our Blog Usage Policy


Want to comment on a blog?

Login and post your comment


Log In
 
 

Register for a free account

Forgot your Password?

Listen Live to West Virginia Public Radio on your Computer or Smartphone

Classically Speaking

Classical music in West Virginia and Beyond

Learning to Love Bruckner

 Permanent link   All Posts
Share/Save/Bookmark
By Mona Seghatoleslami
 · October 14, 2009

This weekend, the WV Symphony will be performing Bruckner’s Fourth Symphony in Fairmont, Charleston, and Parkersburg (on a concert that will also feature guest soloist Jon Nakamatsu performing Rachmaninoff).

Bruckner’s symphonies can be a divisive subject among classical music fans. Have you heard his music? And what do you think of it? I’ve been asking almost everyone that I see about it, and I’d love to hear from you.  Do you side with Berlin critic who called him a second Beethoven, or Eduard Hanslick, who labeled his music "nightmarish hangover style (traumverwirrten Katzenjammerstil)"?

Bruckner 1
Why don't they love me?

As for me, Bruckner and I have a long and troubled relationship.

As a kid, I would go to New Jersey Symphony concerts with my dad. The second half of one concert was a Bruckner symphony. I don’t remember which one. I always had a bit of trouble staying awake at concerts, not because I was bored, but because I wasn’t good at sitting still late at night in a warm, dark room with nice music playing. Normally my little concert naps would fall during a slow, inner movement of some great classical work.

Ah, but Bruckner; I don’t think I even made it through half of the first movement before I was out like a light.  I would wake up every now and then, thinking “oh no, it’s still going.” 

Tastes do change; as a kid, I hated opera and contemporary music. And starting as a teen, I turned against Mozart for about a decade. My feelings about all of these things have definitely changed, but Bruckner and I still have some work to do on our relationship.

In an undergraduate 19th-century music history class, we studied Bruckner’s music.  As we all followed along with the music, our professor played a movement from one of his symphonies.  A friendly classmate shook my shoulder every time my head drooped.

A few years later, in Indiana, I attended a concert. A miracle – I stayed awake! But I still didn’t go out of my way to listen to his music any more after that. 

Bruckner 2
Perhaps we can be friends...

In preparation for this weekend’s concert, I’ve listened to some Bruckner recordings, and I must admit … I’m starting to hear it. A friend described his music as having “cathedral-like phrases” and an “architectural sense of time.” These descriptions have helped me to slow down and appreciate grandeur of  Bruckner’s music.

This BBC program about Bruckner’s Fourth Symphony is a serious antidote for Bruckner-phobia. It was recommended to me by a tuba player from the WV Symphony, and I highly recommend you listen to it.

OK, now that you know the whole sordid history of my relationship with Bruckner, I want to hear from you. Are you a Bruckner fan or foe?

Then visit us on Facebook, where you can win some tickets to hear what the West Virginia Symphony does with Bruckner's Fourth Symphony this weekend.


Dearest Mona,

Came upon your 'Learning to Love Bruckner' piece during an idle few moments. The biographical experiences you remark upon certainly strike a familiar tone. I can only recommend a gentle acceptance of his music - it will, I think, serve one well as the years shape your approach to this ever more frentic and hectic life we all are obliged to share.

As an Englishman, I found the same worked for me with American (NFL) football...now I absolutely love it.

Although my team, the Giants, lost tonight...

Bruckner's 2nd always makes things right!


Hope this finds you in good spirits,

Boskof
Posted by: Boskof at 11/29/2009 9:42 PM


Well, Mona...having made the effort to solicit responses from Bruckner fans out here (in your posting above); it appears to me that it was now maybe more a rhetorical announcement than authentic enquiry. I suppose had you deemed to make any form of acknowledgement. then it would merely be also rhetorical consolation.

Or maybe you all suffer from ADD over there?
Posted by: Boskof at 3/24/2010 8:48 PM


Dear Boskof,

I apologize for the delay in response. Our system now notifies me of responses on these posts, but this system was not in place at the time of your first comment.

I am glad to hear from you about your appreciation of Bruckner. I will make time to listen to the Second Symphony (really! and if I don't reply in a week or two, feel free to tap me on the shoulder, either with a comment here or an email to feedback@wvpubcast.org (make sure to mention that it is for Mona).

I did enjoy the WV Symphony's performance of Bruckner's Symphony No. 4, but again, after the concert and all my preparation...I still didn't seek out more Bruckner. The one exception is his Symphony in D Minor "Die Nullte." I'd hate to think that I'm only drawn to it because it's shorter than the others.

One friend insists that I just need to hear certain conductors and performances to appreciate his music -- that some conductors "get it" better than others.

Whether this reaches you as an authentic response
or simply rhetorical consolation, I do hope it finds you well and not too troubled by the "frenetic and hectic" pace of life.

Best,
Mona
Posted by: Mona( Visit ) at 3/25/2010 10:56 AM


Mona,

a genuine thankyou for your reply, there are, generally speaking, few opportunities to chew the cultural fat these days over minority issues, which I suppose must include Anton Bruckner. I am humbled by your response to an Englishman's anally retentive indignations. Please forgive me.

I know an ocean may seperate our Nations in many ways; but it certainly adds perspective to modern life.

May you sleep well tonight, & wake up happy,

Boskof
Posted by: Boskof at 5/7/2010 8:25 PM


Leave a comment
Name *
Email *
Homepage
Comment

RSS Feed
<< May 2013 >>
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  

Blogroll

Archive

Subjects

Recent Posts

West Virginia Public Broadcasting is a member station of: